Why Slicing is Better Than Harsh Chopping

Crane Pumps & Systems
Crane Chopper pumps

Why Slicing is Better Than Harsh Chopping

Chopper Pumps And Non Clogging

Chopper pumps are used extensively in heavy-duty solids-laden water applications including municipal wastewater, industrial sewage, food processing, agricultural byproduct, and raw untreated drainage run-off from metal, paper and chemical industries.

Chopper pumps increasing popularity can be attributed to the combination of increasing solids loading in water streams and decreasing water drain-off from residential, commercial and industrial sources. Chopper pumps solve the biggest challenge that municipalities and private wastewater treatment operators face – Clogging

Different Chopping Technologies

Several chopper solutions are available in the market. All solutions include two sets of blades or cutters moving against one another, and producing a cutting action on the solids to reduce their size.

The relative movement between the blades or cutters is achieved by usually securing one cutting surface (blade) to the pump casing, and rotating the other cutting surface (blade) by either affixing it to the impeller or by making use of a hardened impeller. The number of cuts per minutes depend on each solution’s design and RPM.

The design, position and relative movement of the cutting surfaces determine the effectiveness of chopping and the ability to reduce solid size. In almost all designs, the rotating cutting surface ‘strikes’ against the stationary cutting surface to produce chopping action. There are very few, if not only one, chopper pumps that are designed to ‘slice’ solids instead of chopping them.

The Barnes Sithe chopper pump’s patented design employs a stationary striker plate and a rotating slicing blade that tears and slices solids. Slicing and chopping actions are analogous to cutting with a scissors and a knife.

Science Behind Chopping Action

The act of chopping consists of two surfaces hitting one another till one survives and the other doesn’t. This creates a ‘compressive explosive force’. At high speeds, such as a pump, the solid being chopped is typically pinched until it can compress no more, and the solid reacts by breaking apart from the inside out. The explosive forces can be high enough to disintegrate the solid into two finer pieces instead of actually chopping the solid from end to end.

Science Behind Slicing Action

The science behind slicing is much different. When a ‘pair of scissors’ cut a solid, the blades’ surfaces slide down the solid, cutting it from the outside in a tearing motion. The cutting force needed to separate a solid in slicing is less because it is distributed across the cutting surfaces at different times instead of all in one moment. The force of cutting a solid is distributed along the cutting surfaces as the solid slides between the cutting surfaces.

Impact On Pump Reliability

Internal components of a chopper pump handling solids laden water experience minimal stress when pumping water.

However, as the cutting surfaces come in contact with a solid, stress increases till the solid is cut and leaves the edges of the cutting surfaces.

Chopping and slicing actions exhibit different levels of stress on a pump’s components. The slicing action’s sliding shear frictional force is relatively less compared to the chopping action’s compressive explosive force.

As a result, the stress on impeller, seals and bearings are lesser in slicing action. When these wear parts are exposed to lower stress levels, they last longer and overall life cycle cost decreases.

Related Articles

Crane Wipes vs. Sewer

Flushable Wipes vs. Sewer Systems

What Are Flushable Wipes? Flushable wipes, also known as non-woven wipes, have many purposes and have become increasingly popular over the…

Crane The Porter Medical Center.

Life Before Chopper Pumps…

Located approximately 35 miles south of Burlington, Vermont, the Porter Medical Center is a medical facility that is an affiliate…

Related Whitepapers

How do variable speed drives impact mechanical seals?

Author: Henri Azibert, FSA Member The use of variable speed drives (VSD) has become increasingly more prevalent in an effort to improve the energy efficiency…

Inpro/Seal Split Air Mizer Installation

This video walks you through how to install a split Inpro/Seal Air Mizer on standard processing equipment.

Which One to Choose – Metallic vs. Non-Metallic Sealless Pumps

Picking a pump can be tricky, as there are a lot of different variables to consider. One of which is metallic or non-metallic. What type…


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up for our Newsletter

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Empowering Pumps & Equipment, 2205-C 7th Street, Tuscaloosa, AL, 35401, http://www.empoweringpumps.com. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact